From: Larson, Rod
Sent: Friday, September 19, 2008 6:45
AM
To: Duemke, Roger
Subject: ISBT
Roger,
Bad News. During the
last max performance test late today on the X actuator, I blew the hell out of
that aluminum valve between the s/v manifold and the actuator. Because of no
accumulation on the system, I could only get about 80% of 1 cycle w/o running
out of oil. I was running at 0.95 Hz at about +/-220 mm when the valve blew
apart. It broke in two pieces and sailed across the lab. The one set of ports
that did not fracture were bowed out about 1/16". AND, because the HSM shunts
pressure to return AND there are NO hand valves in the hard line we lost about
60-70 gallons of oil due to siphoning from the pump before we got all the hoses
off and capped. Good thing I was there cuz Robin had NO idea that the pressure
hose was the BIG culprit. The drain lines were back-flowing too, but at pretty
small flows. The pressure hose to the actuator, being shunted to return by the
HSM, made it so the pump return was open to atmosphere at the actuator. The
return hose has a check valve but counts for nothing because it is shunted by
the pressure dump to return. AND, the return hose has to come off TOO because
the check valve has that DAMN orifice in it. I am NOT perfect in what I do, but
this time I was being VERY careful because the high accelerations were making
some really big banging noises and that was worrying me. I was almost there,
when BAM....game over.
At the time of the
accident, the acceleration was about 7 g's. When the actuator runs out of oil,
the servovalve closes at a bad time and you get horrendous accelerations. This
is not uncommon in seismic. It can easily happen on an E-Stop during any high
velocity motion. The 7g accel turns into about 8000+ psi in the actuator port
which is obviously too much for that aluminum valve. I am bringing back the 2
pieces with me. You can see the dent in the valve end that is towards the table
cuz it hit the table going like a bat out of hell. FYI, I have OFTEN seen 9000
to 10,000 psi spikes on seismic tables. That's why the deltaP snubber will save
the transducer. The psi comes from figuring out how many psi results in so many
g's.....the accelerometer does not lie; therefore, it does reflect
psi....
BTW, what is that
valve for? IT seems to be a flow reducer of some kind. Is that for when the
specimen is that overweight case? Then it makes sense to limit velocity cuz of
the cushions....UNFORTUNATELY, it is in a REALLY bad place for over-pressure.
Maybe there is a better way to do it somewhere else in the flow path that is not
so rife with high pressure.
Obviously, we did
NOT complete acceptance. Robin was planning to stay until Wednesday next week to
work on the 793 w/ the customer some more. He has graciously offered to help
clean up the rest of the oil tomorrow (got about 10 gallons in the pit yet and
the table is sopping wet). He WILL be able to run the 793 next week cuz we got
everything capped off at the HSM. Robin did real yeoman work to dive in there
and get it done. A couple Suviet guys did as well. Otherwise, we might have lost
all the pump oil. It was gushing out......
I can come back to
Vietnam about any time from now through the end of October (November is
full-early december open), but we need to talk about this valve and do something
better I think....
I can call you on
Yahoo Voice for about 1 cent/minute. I will try to call you about 8ish your
time.
Again,,,,,sorry
......(dang it)
Rod